What happens when an academic insider steps away from the institution?
In this episode, Ken visits Pulitzer Prize-winning author Viet Thanh Nguyen at his home. Following his recent retirement from the University of Southern California (USC) after 28 years, Viet opens up about the realities of higher education, the corporate mechanics of major universities, and the psychological freedom of stepping away from academia.
Viet and Kenneth dive into the state of modern America, examining political division, the price of free speech, self-censorship, the impact of AI on writing, and the inspiration behind his upcoming third novel in The Sympathizer trilogy.
Inside the Episode:
Leaving Academia: Navigating institutional constraints, the rising costs of higher education, and the choice to exit a prestigious tenure position.
Capitalism & The University System: How profitability, branding, and corporate interests shape modern American education.
Speech, Controversy, & Freedom: Reflections on speaking out after October 7th, facing public pushback, and the realities of self-censorship.
The Impact of Artificial Intelligence: Why Viet banned technology in his final seminar and how AI challenges the human element of writing.
The Final Chapter of The Sympathizer Trilogy: Moving the story from Paris to El Salvador in 1984, exploring revolutions, US foreign policy, and imperial legacies.
Connect & Follow:
Website: vietNguyen.info
Instagram: @viet.thanh.nguyen.writer
The Vietnamese Podcast: Instagram / TikTok @thevietnamesepodcast
Transcript
Intro:
I don’t remember much. And more and more of those each day, there are faces I recognize without knowing their name. They smile like they know me, so I smile back. I used to have a story. I know I love someone. I know I work hard. I know I come from somewhere far away. I’m glad someone asked me who I was when I see a new. They saved my life and kept my story when I no longer could. So even if I don’t remember where I come from, they will. Even if I look at them and don’t know their names, they still know mine.
Ken:
Welcome to the Vietnamese podcast. Today I am in the home of Viet Nguyen. Viet Nguyen has retired from teaching and I asked Viet if I can join him on a podcast to talk about how he feels about how open he can be with retiring from an institution that perhaps might have held you back, and here to talk about the state of America. Thank you. Welcome to the podcast.
Viet Nguyen:
Glad to be back here with you, Ken.
Ken:
I reflect on every time I sit with you because I feel like I’m getting more comfortable with what I do. And today I thought about it, sitting in your living room while [inaudible 00:02:35] was setting up. And I can’t imagine how you must feel as the years have gone by, and now that you’re out of USC as an institution, how much more relaxed you are. Can you talk a little bit about how free you are? Or it doesn’t really change anything?
Viet Nguyen:
Do I look more relaxed to you yet?
Ken:
No.
Viet Nguyen:
No, not yet. The reality hasn’t really started kicking in yet. I think I got my last paycheck as a professor from USC about a month and a half ago. So the new reality is just starting to arrive. But we met at USC, University of Southern California. And everything I’m going to say about USC is actually, I think, not unique to USC. It’s more indicative of the place of higher education in the United States, which is also indicative of a lot of things about economics and power in American society.
So I’m very grateful to having been a professor at USC for 28 years, gave me a lot of opportunities in different ways, including teaching and meeting people like you. But there’s no doubt that USC, I think, is a symptom of so many different things around power, around the way in which almost everything we do as Americans is tied into profit. So going to USC is an incredibly expensive proposition. I think total cost is somewhere around $90,000 a year right now.
Ken:
That’s crazy.
Viet Nguyen:
That’s crazy, right? But it’s not unusual. And one of the ironies about American higher education is that if you make your costs cheaper, people think your university’s worth less. So that’s not just a fault of higher education. People like to blame higher education for the spiraling costs of universities, but a lot of Americans want to pay more. Not everybody, but some segment wants to pay more and that helps to keep the prices high. And that affects everything we do in a university. Everything becomes, despite the fact that we’re supposed to be pursuing truth and knowledge and all these wonderful things, it’s also saturated by worries about profit, both in terms of someone’s individual pay, but also the profitability of an entire university.
And so I think that was symptomatic of so many other aspects of life in American society, where everything is saturated with the desire for profit, for celebrity, for spectacle, that extends to politics, extends to sports. And USC being this major corporate institution was affected by not just capitalism, but by celebrity, by sports, by spectacle, by politics. So all of these things are intertwined, and I was dependent on that for my salary. So stepping out of it hopefully will, I think as you’re implying, give me more freedom psychologically, but also just in terms of being a writer and saying what I want to say.
Ken:
You know the economics of almost $400,000 a year for an education at USC. When you think about your children, what do you feel like, do they need that? Do you think they’d be all right without something at USC and above?
Viet Nguyen:
Of course. So $400,000 total for four years at USC.
Ken:
It’s 90 and then you add everything in.
Viet Nguyen:
Add everything in. So I went to school at Berkeley at a time when Berkeley cost probably about eight or $900 a semester in tuition, unbelievable. But even now Berkeley is probably $15,000, 12, $15,000. Still an enormous amount of money, but a relative bargain. My wife went to community college for the first two years before she went to UC Santa Cruz. We both came out okay. So there is no doubt in my mind that if my children had decided to go the community college route, they decided to go to the University of California route for a fraction of the cost, they would turn out fine. But there is, again, in the United States, this mentality that more expensive is better. And so people go into debt for that kind of thing, and we really should not have that kind of mindset.
But as a country, we should also be thinking of ways by which things like education or healthcare should be costs that are borne by society as a whole and not just by the individuals who are sending their families to that. And we should be thinking about the ways in which education is wrapped up with so many other things besides education. People go to universities, they want the nice dorms, they want the very successful football team, which requires a very expensive coach, et cetera. And so we have a problem here by way of which education in the United States is also tied into a lot of other kind of problematic values that we as a society hold.
Ken:
This does not sound like it’s going to go away.
Viet Nguyen:
Oh, it’s not going to go away. No, it’s not.
Ken:
It’s impossible for us to go backwards. What are we going to do? How are you going to wipe off this idea of branding per each institution? It’s impossible. You want us to be seen with the Lamborghini degree, the Rolls-Royce degree. You want to be in that elite. Most people, if I’m going to work that hard to get a 4.5 in school, high school, I want to make sure that I make it to Harvard or Yale. Why would we go back?
Viet Nguyen:
I don’t think it’s possible to go back in a capitalist system. A capitalist system is built exactly in what you described, which is ever-increasing wealth and profit as realized at least partly through the visible exhibition of that wealth in a Lamborghini, or in a Harvard degree or whatever it connotes a lot of wealth. However, if American capitalism declines or collapses, it may not be possible to sustain that model anymore. And so that is part of the larger issue, whether capitalism as a whole can sustain the trajectory that it’s on. You can look at other countries, you can look at Western Europe, for example. They have pretty good higher educational systems that cost nowhere near the amount of money that an American higher education would cost. They seem to be doing okay.
Now, are they doing as spectacularly wealthy as the United States as an arguable situation? But I think the American model is built on this mindset that pure capitalism is the only way by which a society can be organized. And the United States has come to represent that to the entire world. But the United States is riven with all kinds of internal contradictions and external pressures. And so the force of change may not come about because Americans want it, but because it’s forced on them by politics and economics.
Ken:
When you walked into USC, you were a young man, and you had certain ideas about teaching and about who you were and about America. Those three things have probably transformed a lot in the last three decades. Can you give me a little color about that?
Viet Nguyen:
Well, I’m middle-aged now. You’re technically middle-aged at this point, and so it’s an age-old story that your illusions have to be tested by realities for every generation. And I think certainly for me, at least when it came to higher education, those illusions were wrapped up with this idea about what higher education should do and could do. And for me, higher education transformed me completely, intellectually, politically, personally. And so I wanted to do some of that work myself for my own students, and I felt that I probably did that in some ways for some people. But part of the fall of the illusion is that no matter what the individual professor does, the institution as a whole veers towards corruption.
Once you have so much money in an institution, whether it’s the military, or the government, or higher education, there’s going to be corruption. USC becomes symbolic of that because we had more than our fair share of corruption and scandals over the past 25 years. It’s really exhausting to recount them all. And they extended not just through football and basketball, but also into our hospital system and things like that. So that was really disillusioning to think that higher education itself is a corporate institution that is undermined by its own desire for increasing recognition, profitability, spectacle, reputation, all this type of business, and that it is inseparable again, from the US as a whole, including the military industrial complex. You’re a veteran and you came to USC through the veteran, the GI Bill, right?
Ken:
Yeah.
Viet Nguyen:
That’s just one symptom of the way by which the American university system is looped into the federal system, which is not only federal research money, but also military industrial complex money as well. So it’s hard to imagine yourself as an individual professor trying to transform your students when they’re in an institution that’s designed to reproduce them to be a part of the American military industrial complex and American domination. So that was hard for me to cope with the further that I got, the higher I rose in the ranks. And by the time I resigned from USC, I was a university professor. That’s the highest rank you can achieve in the university system. I could have stayed in that position for the next 20, 30 years until I died, 40 years making a very high salary, doing very little, and probably nothing would’ve happened to me, but it would’ve been my own way of selling a little bit of my soul to this kind of a system.
And again, that is tied to my understanding of what the United States is. We live in a country in which we are telling our young people that they can rise to the greatest heights if they work hard, get the right education. But what are those greatest heights? What does that even mean to achieve fame, and power, and recognition and success? What are the consequences of that both for oneself as an individual, for US society as a whole, but then also the ramifications for the rest of the world because everything we do in the US, at least for now, impacts the rest of the world.
Ken:
Let’s get into that, because you’re saying something that I have to ask, what do you think you were becoming or what’s holding you back? If you stay in it, what were you not able to do? It sounds like… Let me clarify this. What I’m asking is you’re saying that for you, it just sounds like your freedom is really limited, or this ability to develop into something more or different, by staying you’re in shackles.
Viet Nguyen:
So I’ll go back to the moment when I was 19 or 20 and I was trying to figure out what to do with my life. And I came from a refugee background. I was a refugee, my parents were refugees, my parents did not have higher education, and we never said the word professor or scholar in our house, or PhD. So this is all new to me at 19 or 20, and I decided to get a PhD, go into academia. This was a job that my parents could understand. But I swore to myself that once I achieved tenure, which I just learned about that at 19 or 20, tenure means you have job security and technically the university can’t fire you. I said to myself, once I have tenure, I’ll do whatever I want because they can’t fire me. And I got tenure, and I thought that I partially did what I said I was going to do. I became a writer, which is not what I was hired to do.
But the further I got into the university system, the higher in the ranks I went, the more invitations I got to do things that a lot of people would interpret as signs of success. Join this board, join that other board, could take this invitation to give a lecture or travel internationally. And the more I thought, the more I do this, the more in fact I’m actually becoming incorporated into systems of power. So can I still really do and say whatever I want to do? Because if I do and say whatever I want to do, those opportunities will start to dry up, which when it came to October 7th is precisely what happened. I said, “This is a genocide and I think we should have a ceasefire.” And then that became controversial in ways that had personal consequences for me that were nowhere near as bad as it was for Palestinians or for Muslims, but nevertheless, some measure of that.
That was just one symptom of the way by which the more successful you become in an institutional track, the more you are actually, despite whatever you think about your independence, you are now a part of the system. And part of the disillusionment for me at reaching 40 or 50 was to think, “I’m now part of the system. I’m now the man.” And I remember we were doing a search for the new university president. We were doing these round tables for the university community. I was sitting up there in a dais with a search committee and Rick Caruso, who is Chair of the Board of USC and Chair of the Search Committee. And a young woman stands up and points at all of us and says, “You are all so fat and happy up there.”
Ken:
Wow. A student?
Viet Nguyen:
Yeah, a student. And I was like, “That would’ve been me 20 or 30 years ago.” And now look at me.
Ken:
Now you’re up there.
Viet Nguyen:
Now I’m up there, and you are a part of it no matter what else you’re doing. And so you can still obviously speak out within the system, but there are limitations. And if I had stayed as a professor, I would’ve had to expend so much energy teaching, committee work, meetings, et cetera. These are all necessary for the function of the institution, but they’re also distractions for my time when what I felt was really important, my one talent is to write. And I had to try to give myself the time to do that, and therefore to be the best writer I could be, but also to speak the best truth that I knew.
Ken:
And what did you say to that student that stood up? Did anybody say anything?
Viet Nguyen:
You can’t say anything. If a young person calls you fat and happy, what are you supposed to say? No, I’m not. Because to the young person who is, I’m just going to project onto this person, going tens of thousands of dollars into debt for this education who is 20 or 22 years old, who is in deep anxiety about their place in the world and their future, et cetera, I am fat and happy. There’s nothing I can do. I can’t say, “Oh, 30 years ago I was getting arrested in protests as I was.” That doesn’t make any difference. I am what I am now and she is what she is there. The generational difference is real. And when people in the 1960s were saying, “Don’t trust anyone over 30,” there was some truth to that. There’s exceptions obviously, but on the average, the older you get, the fatter you get, the wealthier you get.
Ken:
The happier you are.
Viet Nguyen:
The happier you are. The more complacent you are with the way things are because they tend to benefit you. Again, not everybody, but the general trajectory is there. And I don’t think she was wrong. So there’s really nothing I could say. And in fact, the search produced a president who pretty much continued to do the very things that USC had always done. And so she was not wrong that the institution would continue in its path.
Ken:
The constraints that are placed on professors and somebody like you in a university setting forces you perhaps to get more creative with the way you protest, the way you communicate to the outside world about your views maybe. But also it gives you a position of power being entrenched in the system when you do finally communicate to the world and say Gaza, genocide, all of these things has a little bit more weight as a University of Southern California professor, or does it not?
Viet Nguyen:
It does. Let me put it this way. There’s a little bit of clout when you have a title and a business card and all that, people will pay a little bit more attention to you. And again, it’s all reputational. I win a prize. People are like, “Oh, I recognize what that prize is. Therefore, you must be worth something. Therefore, we’ll listen to you. You have a title from a university, the same function.” So you do have some clout. Obviously, it’s a little bit easier to approach other institutions of power. Let’s say I want to be published in the New York Times. I can use a little bit of clout to do that. Let’s say I want to have a meeting with the university president. I can do that. However, what change is really going to take place?
The university, again, just USC as a symptom. This is a university with a multi-billion dollar endowment. It’s got tens of thousands of students. It’s got a huge hospital system that’s actually really important to how it operates. Most people don’t know major research universities, a lot of the profit comes out of their hospitals. So you don’t know these kinds of things until you get into the nuts and bolts, and then you don’t know that the board of trustees actually really runs the show. The president is working at their behest.
So how much power does even a president really have? The president could have a vision, but the board of trustees says, “There’s a red line here. You can’t cross it.” The president can’t cross it. So even a president is constrained by all kinds of things that the average person doesn’t see. So yes, you can use your clout to try to enact certain kinds of change within the institution, even outside of it, but the institution, because it’s so deeply invested in literally profitability and money, it’s extremely hard to change the general course of that institution. And so I have so much respect for people who stay within the institution to try to fight it, but the reality of it is that most people in this institution don’t fight it. And I’m hoping that stepping out of it will give me just psychologically and physically just more time to say things without restraint.
Ken:
I’m excited. I look forward to hearing what you have to say next.
Viet Nguyen:
Oh, me too.
Ken:
Would you ever consider teaching again? Do you ever imagine a place in your life where you miss it so much that you get back in?
Viet Nguyen:
The irony is that towards the end of my career, I thought I was better. When I started off as a teacher, I first started teaching when I was 21 or 22 as a Teaching Assistant. My students were my age, some were older. I became a professor at 26, same situation. The advantage there is youth, so I’m a little bit closer to the students, but the disadvantage is lack of wisdom and experience. And so by the end of my career in my early 50s, I felt I had more wisdom. I’d just seen so much with the students. I was more sympathetic. I was more empathetic. I was more caring as a person. I was a lot older than the students, which meant that I also could see them, I think more holistically. They thought of themselves as adults, obviously. I thought of themselves as adults, but also as children in certain ways.
And I found them to be vulnerable and in need of care that I couldn’t provide when I was younger. So I think I got better as a professor, but I was also just more exhausted, and I felt that I had lost the passion for teaching that I had when I was 25 or 26. And so what was the question again?
Ken:
God, now I’ve lost my train of though because I’m listening to you. We can move on. I think-
Viet Nguyen:
We can splice it in.
Ken:
How are the students today different than when you first started?
Viet Nguyen:
I don’t think the students of today are basically very much different than from when I started. And they’re different if you look at a specific situation like USC, it went from being the University of Spoiled Children when I started, to University of Serious Connections or Corruption, depending on your point of view. And SATs, GPAs are way, way better. Students are intellectually better equipped. But emotionally, the way they look at the world, I think they’re the same. They’re all 18 to 21 on the average, lots of anxiety, lots of excitement, lots of exuberance, lots of ambition, lots of questions. All that I think has stayed the same. What’s also stayed the same is that there’s going to be a certain percentage who are going to be disabled in certain ways, disabled by the economics of their situation.
I mean disabled, not in a negative sense. I’m just saying they don’t have the same opportunities that some people have come in with because they come from family wealth and generational experience with academia. There’s always going to be a percentage who feels like they’re out of place because they didn’t come in with parents with wealth. They didn’t come in with multiple generations of college graduates, or they didn’t come in with a whole body or a whole mind. They have other kinds of issues. That’s always there. And so that’s what I mean when I say that I have a better understanding of the vulnerability of students. There are students who are vulnerable individually because they have a learning challenge, or they’re vulnerable individually because they have a mental health issue. There are students who are collectively vulnerable because they’re a part of a vulnerable population. All of that is there as well.
So the specifics can change, but I think that whole picture of the student population has not. Now there are specific things like social media, artificial intelligence that characterize this generation that we didn’t have in our generations, and that is a real thing. And one reason I quit is because I didn’t want to deal with artificial intelligence. If I’d stayed, I would have had to deal with it and we all have to deal with it, but I didn’t want to deal with that. And so every generation has its own particular kinds of new technical political issues that they have to confront, but the overall emotional tenor I think is the same.
Ken:
Same. And do you think when we introduce AI into actual learning for the students to integrate it into their essays or their writing, do you think that we have a way to mitigate them from actually doing the work? I guess what I’m asking, is there a way to incorporate it and have them do the work and have them do the actual critical thinking?
Viet Nguyen:
Yeah, there is. I have faith that we can do it. I don’t have faith that we will do it. Okay, so I’ll give you an example. The very last class that I taught was a nine-person seminar, and in that nine-person seminar, there was no electronics, so they couldn’t bring any device into the classroom. They had to do writing in class every time we met.
Ken:
This is per you, your idea to do this?
Viet Nguyen:
Oh yeah, but it’s not unusual. A lot of professors are now turning into this, for example. The only time they could use a computer was at home when they wrote their final paper. That was the only thing they could do at home. And their final exam was actually one-on-one oral examination with me for 30 minutes, which I think is actually more terrifying than having to write a paper. So that means that it’s completely possible to do a kind of education where you separate the human being from all the technology. I think it’s very doable. Now, the problem is, it’s labor-intensive. I could have done that with 15 or 30 students. Could I do it with 150 students, which was my largest class? So that’s the issue.
Again, going back to the cost-profit model of education, right now, everything’s being driven by profitability. They’re bringing in AI. The majority of professors and teachers in higher education are actually non-tenure track, which means non-permanent. They’re paid subpar wages. They’re economically vulnerable. They have enormous teaching loads. The boutique educations that go on at very expensive universities I think will incorporate AI, and also at the same time try to increase the human touch in the model that I just described. But the entire model of higher education as a whole is driven by mass market profitability where each student is a consumer who’s paying a lot of money, but it’s also a site of profit in terms of how much the lower amount of resources can be invested in a student, the greater the profit the university can extract.
So a 10-person class, a 30-person class, that’s less profitable than 150 or 1,000 person distance education course. So this is where I’m pessimistic that the temptations to use AI to do that at the expense of a student’s ability to learn and the teacher’s ability to teach, that temptation is what’s being offered to us right now, versus this other model where AI could be used as a supplement. So for example, I do it now, not by choice, but if you do a Google search now, it defaults automatically to AI. Now, the sad thing is it’s actually so far seems to be pretty good.
Ken:
Very good. Yeah.
Viet Nguyen:
When I do stuff that I don’t know anything about, like what kind of bike should I buy? I turn to AI and it’s worked. Now you transport that to education or any other kind of professional field, and the temptation obviously is that then people don’t have a sense of expertise in their own area. I’m writing a novel and I’ll use AI to help me do research, but I know how to incorporate that research into my own work without plagiarizing it, or I have a sense of when to trust it and when not to trust it. A new generation of people, or a generation of people who don’t have that long history of professionalization and expertise, they may not be able to do that incorporation, and that’s what we should be teaching them. And I’m not sure that we are going to be teaching people how to use AI versus having AI use us.
Ken:
Since we’re on this topic, I was not going to talk about this, but since we’re here on AI and writing, I’m experiencing this problem is that when I go to write things for myself that I want to make it sound like me. I write it, I get 1,000 words in, and I’m like, I really want this to be spit shined a little bit in terms of the structure. But what ends up happening is, AI rewords things and makes it sound far better than what I can make it sound like. And it doesn’t sound like me. But how do I use it to help me restructure, make things better without… How do you do that without having it restructure your words? Or put words into your writing, and take it out and edit it?
Viet Nguyen:
Great question. I was thinking about the exact same thing because I saw a picture on my social media feed today of Japanese soldiers on the beach in Singapore around a group of Chinese prisoners. And I looked at that picture and I was like, “That’s AI because it’s too clean.” If this is an actual picture of World War II where this was taking place, it would look grainy, et cetera, et cetera. And here it is so polished, I knew that even though the situation actually happened, the image itself most likely did not happen. So the literary equivalent is the same thing. What you described is probably going to be the future where everybody sounds the same.
Just like that AI image, it looks the same as a thousand other AI images because it’s been made by a machine. The writing is going to be the same model. And so you could be writing to somebody else and they’re going to write back to you and you’ll be like, “You guys will sound exactly alike.” And of course the danger is 50 years from now, no one will know or care because that’s what they’ve been raised with. But in your situation, let’s say that you feed AI 1,000 words, AI gives you 1,000 words back that’s been rewritten. I’m not advocating that anybody does this, but what you would have to do is go back and mess it up, scuff it up. It’s like getting a pair of brand new jeans and you want it to look like the way you want it to look, you mess it up in various ways.
So you have to actually make it look less than perfect. And then people will be like, “Oh, that’s Ken. He’s less than perfect.” It’s a little less than polished. It’s like looking at a Hollywood movie star. You can tell when someone’s had plastic surgery, they look too perfect. So you have to introduce the human, which is imperfection, which is also style at the same time. But it’s very tempting. I turned on my email yesterday and Outlook offered me three sample responses to someone that’s female. I was like, “Oh my God.”
Ken:
It’s pretty amazing.
Viet Nguyen:
I’m actually tempted to use one because it will substitute me having to think doing some kind of bureaucratic thing I don’t want to do, but I did not give into that.
Ken:
Speaking of scuffling up things. When you won your Pulitzer, what I think about in the last week thinking about this conversation that we’re going to have, I thought about once you win a prize like that, you can laterally move into a university like Harvard, or Yale, or some higher, like the pinnacle of the United States. Why didn’t you do that? Was that ever even a thought to you? And is it really important to be at one of those institutions as a professor?
Viet Nguyen:
I think for many professors it is important because again, academics, like a lot of people, are driven not just by their pure pursuit of knowledge, but by the trappings of their life, their profession.
Ken:
Why didn’t you ever move on? Move up?
Viet Nguyen:
Yeah. So what you would do is you would move on to the next highest ranked university, et cetera. And for me, in my case, I got an offer from Princeton, for example, and I didn’t take it. And partly it’s because honestly, I live in California, my wife lives in California, it’s really hard to leave. And she was like, “New Jersey? No way I’m going to New Jersey.” And also for me, Princeton and everything that it represents, and Harvard where I did a couple of fellowships. Once I was exposed to Harvard, for example, where my brother went to school, but I got rejected, once I was exposed to Harvard for a year, I realized I think Harvard is full of you know what. They’re very smart. A lot of very smart people at the faculty level and undergraduate level, there’s no doubt about it, but there’s a certain amount of self-congratulation for being at Harvard.
And that’s not unique to Harvard. When you climb the corporate ladder, I’m sure there’s a lot of self-congratulation once you become a CEO or something like that. And so people who again, who are in the institution, in the particular world that gives them rewards with titles and all this kind of stuff, they accept that world for what it is. I prefer being on the outside. I’m at USC, but I can see hopefully USC from the outside. I could have gone to Princeton and seen it from the outside. I gave the most prestigious lectures that you could give at Harvard University, and I gave those lectures in a very self-conscious way where I drew attention to the anomaly of being a refugee giving these lectures at Harvard University. And so that was why, I think I’m just very skeptical of the things that I’m not supposed to be skeptical about.
If Harvard gives you an invitation to be a professor, you’re supposed to take it. So when they gave me the invitations to give these Norton lectures at Harvard, I took it groaning because I knew I would say yes because I’m a model minority, but I knew I would never probably take a job at Harvard. You’d asked me earlier if I would ever teach again. The only place I would ever teach again I think would be Berkeley, where I went to school, because that’s so much sentimental to Berkeley, but I would never do it full-time. I would just do it to be around students for a while.
Ken:
You remind me of the book, The Monk Who Sold His Ferrari.
Viet Nguyen:
Oh, the title.
Ken:
Yeah. The title is just, I think deep down inside you have these Buddhist, you have this real… For me, you can’t hide the fact that you could have made the decision to move on to a Princeton. When I look at you, when I’ve thought about it, I’m like, “Viet could have moved on to higher grounds, but you didn’t.” And it really just shows how real you are. And then now I’m really hoping to see the real Viet come out.
Viet Nguyen:
But we’re all contradictory creatures. I didn’t go to Princeton, but I still stayed at USC, for example. I understand the Buddhist thing. I’m also Catholic. The Catholic idea of giving up the world is the same universe as the Buddhist idea as well. I’m dwelling on this one line from the Bible that I heard many times as a young person that it’s harder for-
Ken:
A rich man.
Viet Nguyen:
A rich man to lose his wealth, or give up his wealth as for a camel to go through the eye of a needle. I think it’s really true. So I have these inclinations, but look at my house. So am I going to give this up? I just don’t want to do that. So I recognize the contradictions of myself, and I think we all have contradictions and that’s what makes us human. So I think I’m not saying these things in order to be resigned to the contradictions. I’m saying these things in order to recognize the contradictions and to be aware that I at least, and hopefully all of us are trying to struggle through our contradictions to, not to resolve them, but get to the next level of contradictions that we have to confront.
Ken:
Speaking of which, America is a contradiction today. I go to Vietnam quite a bit to visit my brother and nobody’s allowed to talk about politics. Not even inside the house are they encouraged, or everybody’s just so tight. Nobody’s talking about politics. And it just seems that people are more content with their family members because there’s no political discourse. There’s no red and blue. Everybody is on the same team.
Is it better to have that where nobody’s talking about that, but they’re all getting along? I no longer talk to anybody in my family in the way that I did when we were maybe 15 years ago, when we were all having a great time, and we’re drinking together and we’re such a close family. Nobody. I know I’m not the only one. What do you think?
Viet Nguyen:
It’s an old trade-off. The society, or the party, or the government, or the individual who promises to give order and stability always does that as part of a bargain. I’ll make everything calm. I’ll make everything happy, but you have to give up certain things. And so the only question is how much are you willing to give up? I don’t have an answer for you, because I haven’t been to Vietnam since 2014. And part of the reason I haven’t been to Vietnam is because I’m very political, and much of my work is not allowed to be published in Vietnam, for example. And the TV series of The Sympathizer was basically not allowed to be shot in Vietnam.
So for someone like me and my particular inclinations, it’s not a great place to be. But I recognize that for a lot of people it is, because I can see the pictures from your account and from all my other friends from social media. It looks great. Vietnam has been totally transformed in the past 12 years in ways that I assume are really good. And so I’m sad that I can’t participate in that joy and pleasure and all those kinds of things. But even in Vietnam, I assume that the picture you’re painting is not completely accurate, because not everybody’s benefiting from it. And there’s some people in prison because they have said what they wanted to say, not even in ways that are super threatening to the government.
So there is a price to be paid. It just may not be being paid by the people that you are encountering. And the flip side of it here in the United States, absolutely fractious like you say, but that’s partly the cost of having democracy. And this is not new in American society. You said that we’re full of contradictions right now in the United States. We’ve always been a contradictory country going back to the very origins and the divisions that you’re describing. Well, we had a whole Civil War about that. Things got much more violent back then. And so it’s not as if this stuff hasn’t happened before. Just for some of us, it hasn’t happened within our generation. Again, some of us, so it hasn’t happened within our generation. And so it’s difficult. And if you’ve lost that sense of unity, it’s painful.
But I don’t know if the answer is then to think of things in a binary model. The binary model is what Donald Trump is offering, and what MAGA is offering, which is we’re just going to suppress all dissent. We’re going to take total control of the political order. You won’t need to be unhappy because we’ll be the greatest country on earth. That’s the promise. So someone has to give up something very substantial for that promise of stability to be realized.
Ken:
As we’re inching towards closer control, government control, authoritarianism, a lot of us think that that’s happening. If you ever get locked up, what would you do?
Viet Nguyen:
Interesting question. I think that if it was purely a personal consequence, it would be fine. It would suck obviously, but it would be fine.
Ken:
It’d be fine.
Viet Nguyen:
It would be fine, because I will pay the price for whatever it is that I said. But I think my real fear is actually penalties for my family.
Ken:
Which is very real.
Viet Nguyen:
That’s very real, but that’s what really happens in a truly brutal society. They don’t just take you out, they take out your family.
Ken:
They let you live and they take them out.
Viet Nguyen:
All kinds of miserable, horrible things can happen. And it’s been done in the United States to indigenous peoples, to native peoples, to Black people in this country. Mass deportations have been done before. So we already see that happening, obviously. It’s like children are being deported because of whatever it is that their parents are alleged to have done. So it’s happened. And so that’s the real fear is that family will pay the price versus just me, myself. So if it was just me, then it would be fine. I think my family’s taken care of and all of that, but I worry about my family. Just as I worry about going back to Vietnam is like, “Well, if they lock me up, okay, I asked for it. I get that, but I don’t want anything to happen to my family if we go back to Vietnam.” So that’s the best answer I can give.
Ken:
Do you ever worry about it? Do you ever think that it’s coming?
Viet Nguyen:
Yeah, but I also think that I don’t want to have an inflated sense of my own self-importance. I think you see right now, for example, which kinds of writers have been penalized the most in American society, or people who write, whether they’re professional writers or not? In recent memory, it’s been Palestinians. Palestinian activists who have spoken up or written something, they’re the ones deported, or threatened with deportation or actually incarcerated. If we look a little bit further past into American history, it’s been primarily or oftentimes Black writers, and Black intellectuals who have had terrible things done to them. Paul Robeson, I think of him, for example, he spoke up, marked as a communist. He couldn’t leave the country because his passport was taken away from him. His career was destroyed because of his activism. And he was one of the greatest, most famous artists of the mid-20th century.
So you can be totally taken down by the US government if they want to do it.
Ken:
Yeah, I think it’s totally possible. I don’t think it’s that far away. It’s a real possibility. And I think this, even if it doesn’t get to that, whatever damage is happening right now is really me. I’m a nobody. I’m just thinking about censoring myself when I’m making these clips. I want to say more, but I’m self-centering. So that in itself is a punishment already, that we’re already being limited by what we can say. But a lot of people said, “Screw it. Why don’t you just really put it out there?” Because it is terrorizing.
Viet Nguyen:
Well, you’ve already burned bridges with your family, I guess, or vice versa. I don’t know who burned bridges with who. But you’re only able to say and do certain kinds of things. You told me you feel freer when you’re able to say what it is that you feel like saying, right?
Ken:
Yeah. But I don’t have the full conviction just yet. But I have a feeling that once I do fly off the handle, I don’t hold back. I’ve told you the messes that I’ve gotten into in the past.
Viet Nguyen:
Well, speaking about contradictions, we supposedly live in a country of freedom. We’re free, but a lot of people, even with a technical sense of freedom, as you say, self-censor. They self-censor unconsciously oftentimes, or they self-censor deliberately. They know what they believe in, but they won’t let themselves say it, whatever it happens to be. And you could argue that this is across the spectrum, that’s why the right wing is saying, “Hey, wokeism is bad because people are being censored for their beliefs.” And it is true. I think we should be critical of all kinds of orthodoxies, whether it’s right, or left or in between. But I think that the real penalties, the real power is still being directed towards the liberal to left spectrum in terms of where the real punishment is being done.
If white people feel like they can’t say certain epithets anymore, are they being censored? Maybe, but they’re being censored from being racist, and sexist, and transphobic, which is different than being censored by demanding greater egalitarianism or freedom for the American people. So there’s different kinds of self-censorship that can take place and they’re not all the same.
Ken:
Do you feel like we’re in America in a state of decline? Do you think we’re in a free fall?
Viet Nguyen:
I think it’s inarguable we’re in a state of decline. And I think that if you want to be optimistic, you can say America could rescue itself, but I don’t think it’s going to happen. Now, whether the decline is fast and crashes hard, or whether the decline is slow, that remains to be seen. But I think that the pathway for the United States to actually pull itself out of free fall or decline is very, very clear. The United States is a capitalist country at its core. And whatever you think about capitalism, you could argue that capitalism could be better for the people that it’s supposed to serve. How do you do that? You do that by distributing the profits of capitalism more equitably to the people within society. Greater taxation, redistributed income, greater social networks, universal basic income. The pathways I think are very, very clear.
Now, can we do it? And I think the contradictions in American society that have generated inequality, the fear of being taxed, the fear of the government, et cetera, I think that force is so strong that I’m extremely pessimistic that even the people who are most invested in capitalism would be able to save it, because they believe that unrestrained capitalism is the only way to do things.
Ken:
And we were almost built on this whole idea of with the Tea Party and with the taxation of England, and at the root, we don’t believe in taxation or minimizing that taxation. So I don’t see it getting better. And I don’t see the Vietnamese community really understanding that communism and giving back, taking from a little bit from the rich is not communism. And we’re just a tiny fraction of America that believes in this kind of wonky, let’s just take everything we can. But I think there’s a lot of people suffering at the bottom.
Viet Nguyen:
No, I don’t disagree, obviously. So that’s what I’m saying. First of all, let me frame this by saying I’m not a believer in capitalism, but if you are a believer in capitalism, you should do all you can to try to save it, and to restrain it because that’s the only way capitalism can actually survive as a part of a national society. Capitalism unrestrained, I think leads to the destruction of nations, because ultimately you look at what’s happening right now, for example, with the billionaire tax in California, and the billionaire’s response is, “To hell with you, we’re going to go to Florida.” But imagine that on a greater scale. It is happening on a greater scale. You can’t restrain billionaires. If a nation decides that say we’re going to tax billionaires, or have greater taxes on billionaires or wealth taxes, the billionaires will say, “Well, we’re going to go to Singapore.” That’s what’s going to happen.
So the people who are most invested in capitalism are invested in capitalism first, the national identity or community identity second. And that’s why I think America’s in a state of decline, because despite all the professions of belief in America and so on that Trump and MAGA are making, it’s ultimately really about the survival of the individual.
Ken:
This might not be a clean cut answer, or I’m not looking for a clean cut answer, but do you think that MAGA and all of these people who are really on the other side of this argument are really in it because they think that it’s actually better for America and for themselves? Or do you think that this is just all out greed?
Viet Nguyen:
Well, I think it depends on who you’re talking about. I think that at the very highest levels, I think it is about greed. I think that if you looked into the soul of souls of some of these people, no matter what they’re saying in public, I think they’re probably very deeply cynical. There are some segment of people who actually know, I think, what’s going on. It’s a planet of finite resources. It’s a vulnerable planet. Many billions of people will suffer because of capitalism, but if I can get mine, then it’s okay. If I can form my little space colony, or my island refuge, or get a bunker in New Zealand, it’s okay. That’s creative destruction. It’s a part of capitalism. They can’t say that in public. They’ll just blame the masses for leading to the destruction of society.
Now, the average participant in MAGA, I think that for them, I think that they do believe that capitalism provides all the answers, and that if anybody given a fair shot can make their way in capitalism and those who fail, that’s their responsibility. But part of what’s going on for them is that they really do think the country has been invaded, both by brown people, and immigrants, and refugees, but also invaded by these foreign ideas around trans identity and things like that. And so I think they really do believe in that, that if you cleanse society of these infiltrations and these sort of subversive ideas, that it will be a better place.
Ken:
What are you working on next?
Viet Nguyen:
So I wrote a novel called The Sympathizer, and it’s about the Vietnam War. And for me, it was always about more than the Vietnam War. It was always about us as Vietnamese people, but more than that as well. And that’s why I had to write a sequel called The Committed, which takes place in Paris, because I wanted to talk about French colonialism and not just American imperialism. And to show that what I was also really interested in was the very nature of revolution, American Revolution, Vietnamese Revolution, French Revolution. We’re all of us living in the legacies of the American and French revolutions, those of us who live in the West and those of us who have been colonized by the West. And for those of us who are Vietnamese, we’ve been affected by the Vietnamese Revolution, whatever you think about it. So these forces of revolution that have been unleashed upon the world have transformed it in so many ways, and you and I are the direct consequences of all those revolutions.
So the third and final novel is what I’m writing now, and it starts in El Salvador in 1984. The Committed ends in Paris in 1984. And of course, I think the reaction for some readers would be like, why is a Vietnamese American guy writing about El Salvador in 1984? And it’s because the moment that the United States lost in Indochina, it immediately pivoted to Central America. Nicaragua had been lost to the Sandinistas, and Ronald Reagan said, “El Salvador is now the new center of the so-called Cold War. If we don’t stop the communists who took over Nicaragua, they’re going to take El Salvador, and Honduras, and Guatemala, as they took Cuba, and then they’ll be right there on our southern doorstep.”
And so for me, I want to be able to connect all those different things. And my protagonist from the first two novels, you have to read the novel to find out why, ends up in El Salvador in 1984 and then makes his way north to Ronald Reagan’s America of 1984, which is also a symbolic year. And that will hopefully be the very, I know it will be the end of his story and the end of the trilogy because I’d like to move on to other things.
Ken:
What would you move on to?
Viet Nguyen:
I have many ideas.
Ken:
Oh, really? Can you name one or two things?
Viet Nguyen:
I’d like to write a fun, satirical comic novel about exactly what we’ve been talking about, the contemporary pitfalls and contradictions of the United States, which is really sad, but also really painfully funny at the same time.
Ken:
How do you manage to direct yourself to say, “I have a lot of ideas, but I’m going to sit and finish this?” Because that’s like an iron will to do that. And I know a lot of people that we try to create and creative people and we’re just so full of ideas. But speaking for myself, just to finish one thing is such a big mountain to climb.
Viet Nguyen:
It’s like running. I love the Haruki Murakami book, What We talk About When We Talk About Running, because it’s about him running marathons. The guy’s crazy. He runs all these marathons and ultra marathons and so on, but he’s treating it as a metaphor for writing. You put one foot in front of the other, it’s painful. You only see a certain distance ahead of you, but if you keep at it, eventually you’re going to run the marathon. And so I think that is my way of approaching a creative project. It is important to have a goal, an object in the end that you can visualize no matter how distant and far away it is, or how immense the goal seems. But you can’t think that you’re going to finish this project the next day, or the next week, or the next month or the next year. You have to think about one little bit at a time.
So for me, literally it’s getting up in the morning and thinking, what’s the next scene? What’s the end of the chapter going to be like? I just got to focus on that and if I do it 24 times, I’ve got a novel. So that kind of work, I think psychologically you have to get yourself into that mindset. I don’t know what kind of larger project you have in mind, but I think they can all be broken down into small bits.
Ken:
I’ve always wanted to finish a memoir. I’ve been at it for six years and I just can’t… It’s so difficult to sit and to finish.
Viet Nguyen:
Yeah. So the writer Richard Russo has an obscene idea when it comes to writing, which is, you have to, I’m going to substitute a suitable word, poop out all the bad drafts before you get to the good draft. I think that’s basically true.
Ken:
Or vomit.
Viet Nguyen:
Or vomit, whatever. You just write, write, write. As long as you can write a bunch of stuff, in the end, let’s say you write 2,000 pages and you’re going to extract 200 pages out of that. It sounds depressing. You’re going to have to write 2,000 pages, but-
Ken:
I have the opposite of writer’s block. I write too much. I have too many ideas, and it’s hard to get a cohesive strategy together to kind of-
Viet Nguyen:
Well, same thing, you write the 2,000 pages, and then you look at it and you find out what’s usable from all of that. It’s like the idea of the sculpture with a block of marble. They have to carve out what’s not relevant, but you won’t be able to carve anything out until you’ve actually got that block of marble, those 2,000 pages in front of you. And it can take time. Six years is a long time in some ways, but it took me 17 years to write a short story collection. So I have sympathy for you, but it’s also realistic that sometimes a book can take decades to write.
Ken:
Yeah. Yeah.
Viet Nguyen:
It doesn’t mean though that it’s sequential. It doesn’t mean you have to finish that project before you do another project. I was writing three books at the same time. And so that’s why some people said, “Oh, you’re so prolific. You published three books in three years.” And I was like, “Well, yeah, but I was working on one book for 17 years. I was working another book for 11 years. I was working on another book for three years.” They were all happening simultaneously.
Ken:
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Amazing. Viet, thank you so much for doing this. I look forward to what it looks like next year when we get together, because these intervals are so interesting, I think, for myself to track my own growth as I’m listening to myself listening to you, and to actually hear the different stages of your life.
Viet Nguyen:
Cool. Always great to talk to you, Ken.
Ken:
Thank you. Thank you.
Conclusion:
Thank you for listening to the Vietnamese with Kenneth Wynn. Special thanks to Brittany Tran, to Jane Nguyen, Katherine Nguyen, Tina Pham, Sydney Jamie, and Crystal Trinh. Please find us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok at the Vietnamese Podcast.